SportsCalendar SportsTips BetWiser SportsBookie
BETWISERBet smarter, not bigger

BASEBALL · MLB

Pittsburgh PiratesvSt. Louis Cardinals

Final resultPittsburgh Pirates def. St. Louis Cardinals · 2–1

Listed start: Thursday 24 September 2026, 4:36 pm UTC

Pittsburgh Pirates$1.6461% implied
St. Louis Cardinals$2.3542.6% implied

Best-of-market odds when this analysis was generated · combined margin ~3.5%. Prices move constantly — check current markets.

After the match

Writing a quick retrospective on how the market read this one…

The matchup

The Pittsburgh Pirates enter this matchup with a record of 35 wins and 33 losses from 68 games, showcasing a solid average of 4.6 points for and 4.4 points against. Recently, they have been in impressive form, winning their last five games, including a notable 2-0 victory over the St. Louis Cardinals on September 22. This recent streak includes several high-scoring outings, such as an 8-5 win against the Kansas City Royals and a 7-4 victory against the Milwaukee Brewers. Their potent offense has been key to their success in recent matchups.

On the other hand, the St. Louis Cardinals have struggled with a record of 26 wins and 35 losses over 61 games, averaging 4.3 points for and 4.4 points against. Their recent performance has been less favorable; they lost four of their last five games, including two defeats to the Pirates. Notably, they were outscored significantly in their recent games against the Washington Nationals, falling 1-9 in one instance. Their head-to-head record this season shows that the Pirates have won two of the three encounters so far, with the Cardinals managing just one victory early in the season. The trend of the Pirates winning suggests a shift in dominance in this rivalry, which could impact expectations for the upcoming match.

Does the price match the form?

The current best-of-market decimal odds indicate the following implied probabilities: Pittsburgh Pirates at $1.64 with a 61.0% implied probability, and St. Louis Cardinals at $2.35 with a 42.6% implied probability. The market total stands at 103.5%, which reflects the combined bookmaker margin.

When examining the implied probability for the Pirates, it's consistent with their recent performance and overall season record. Their winning streak and recent head-to-head success against the Cardinals support the market's view. However, one might question whether the Cardinals' potential for an upset is being underestimated given their ability to score close in previous matchups. Is there a risk in assuming the Pirates will continue their dominance given the Cardinals' capacity to surprise in pivotal games?

Where to look in the markets

Two markets worth exploring based on the data are the head-to-head and the totals over/under markets. The Pirates' scoring average of 4.6 and the Cardinals' average of 4.3 suggest a combined total of around 9 points, which should be compared against the bookmaker's posted totals line for over/under bets. Given the Pirates' recent offensive output and the Cardinals' potential for explosive games despite their struggles, there may be value in assessing the line for both sides.

Additionally, examining player props could yield insights, particularly if there are notable performances in the recent Pirates victories that could translate into player-specific bets. For example, the offensive contributions seen in their last five matches warrant scrutiny. Ultimately, informed comparisons to the posted lines can help identify any discrepancies that might offer value.

Before you bet, check

  • What is the current injury status of essential players for both teams?
  • What are the weather conditions expected for the venue on game day?
  • How does the travel schedule impact the Cardinals following their last matchup?
  • Are there any recent roster changes or player selections that could influence performance?

Staking this game

With the shortest price of $1.64 requiring a 61% strike rate to break even, disciplined staking is crucial. A flat staking strategy of 1-2% of your bankroll can help mitigate the effects of inevitable losing streaks, even when backing strong favorites like the Pirates.