SportsCalendar SportsTips BetWiser SportsBookie
BETWISERBet smarter, not bigger

BASEBALL · MLB

Pittsburgh PiratesvSt. Louis Cardinals

Final resultSt. Louis Cardinals def. Pittsburgh Pirates · 5–1

Listed start: Wednesday 23 September 2026, 10:41 pm UTC

Pittsburgh Pirates$1.9052.6% implied
St. Louis Cardinals$2.0848.1% implied

Best-of-market odds when this analysis was generated · combined margin ~0.7%. Prices move constantly — check current markets.

After the match

Writing a quick retrospective on how the market read this one…

The matchup

The Pittsburgh Pirates are coming into this matchup with a record of 35 wins and 33 losses over 68 games, showcasing a balanced offensive and defensive performance with an average of 4.6 runs scored and 4.4 runs against. Their form is particularly strong, having won their last five games, which includes a recent 2-0 victory over the St. Louis Cardinals on September 22. This continued success reflects their ability to perform well at home, where they have been adept at securing narrow victories, evidenced by three games against the Kansas City Royals that they won by just a single run.

In contrast, the St. Louis Cardinals have struggled with 26 wins and 35 losses from 61 games. They average 4.3 runs scored but allow 4.4 runs against, indicating some vulnerability in their pitching staff. The Cardinals have lost four of their last five games, including the recent shutout against the Pirates. This downturn in form can be alarming, especially when considering their previous meetings this season where the Pirates have managed to edge out the Cardinals twice before their last encounter. The Cardinals did manage a win against them in late August, but their overall upward trend appears less certain compared to the Pirates' recent surge.

Does the price match the form?

The current best-of-market decimal odds reflect the following implied probabilities: Pittsburgh Pirates at $1.90 equals a 52.6% implied probability, while the St. Louis Cardinals at $2.08 represents a 48.1% implied probability. The total market, including the bookmaker margin, stands at 100.7%. Given these numbers, there seems to be a clear discrepancy when comparing Pittsburgh's implied probability with their recent performances. The Pirates have shown strong consistency with their winning streak and defensive solidity, especially at home. In contrast, the Cardinals' shaky record, particularly in recent games where they've encountered difficulties scoring runs, raises questions about whether the market adequately reflects their current form. Is the disparity in recent form between the Pirates and the Cardinals influencing these odds, or could there be underlying factors that merit further exploration?

Where to look in the markets

  • Head-to-Head: Consider Pittsburgh’s strong head-to-head results against St. Louis this season, indicating a potential market edge for the Pirates.
  • Totals Over/Under: With a combined scoring average of 9 points when both teams hit their season numbers, compare this against the bookmakers' posted line to gauge scoring expectations.
  • Player Props: Examine individual performance metrics of key players that could sway scoring in a game with high stakes, particularly considering Pittsburgh's recent offensive output.

Before you bet, check

  • Are there any last-minute injuries affecting today's rosters for either team?
  • What are the weather conditions for outdoor venues, and how might they impact gameplay?
  • Has there been any notable travel fatigue from the away team that could affect performance?
  • Are the starting pitchers confirmed, and how have they performed in recent outings?
  • What is the turnaround time for St. Louis after their recent games, and could that factor into their preparedness?

Staking this game

With the shortest price in the market sitting at $1.90, a successful strike rate of 53% is required just to break even. Adopting a disciplined staking approach, consider implementing a 1-2% flat staking strategy, allowing for the inevitable losing runs that can occur even with strong betting favorites.